Fact Check: Diet Pepsi by TikTok star Addison Rae was really good but her newer songs are flops

Claim Analysis: "Diet Pepsi by TikTok star Addison Rae was really good but her newer songs are flops"

1. Introduction

The claim under examination is that "Diet Pepsi," a song by TikTok star Addison Rae, is a successful release, while her subsequent songs are considered "flops." This assertion raises questions about the reception of Rae's music and the criteria used to define success or failure in the music industry.

2. What We Know

Addison Rae released "Diet Pepsi" on August 9, 2024, through Columbia Records, marking her major label debut and her first single in three years since "Obsessed" (2021) 1. The song has received widespread critical acclaim, with various sources noting its catchy lyrics and refined production 47. Critics have compared it favorably to the work of established artists like Lana Del Rey 810.

In contrast, Rae's earlier single "Obsessed" was met with a lukewarm reception and did not achieve significant mainstream success 8. The claim that her newer songs are "flops" lacks specificity, as it does not identify which songs are being referred to or provide metrics for evaluating their success.

3. Analysis

Reception of "Diet Pepsi"

The reception of "Diet Pepsi" has been largely positive. Sources such as Rolling Stone and Redbrick Music highlight the song's catchy nature and Rae's improved vocal performance compared to her previous work 42. Critics have noted that "Diet Pepsi" represents a significant step forward in Rae's music career, suggesting that it has resonated well with both fans and critics 7.

However, the term "flops" regarding her newer songs is vague and subjective. While "Diet Pepsi" has been successful, it is unclear how subsequent releases have performed. For instance, if Rae has released other songs after "Diet Pepsi," their performance metrics (such as chart rankings, streaming numbers, or critical reviews) would be necessary to substantiate the claim of them being "flops."

Source Reliability

1. Wikipedia: Generally reliable for basic facts, but may lack depth and is subject to user edits 1.
2. Redbrick Music: A music review site that provides subjective opinions; potential bias exists based on the reviewer's preferences 2.
3. Rolling Stone: A well-respected music publication known for its critical reviews, but it may have a tendency to favor mainstream artists 4.
4. Punkee: An entertainment site that offers a mix of news and reviews; reliability may vary based on the author's expertise 8.
5. Hollywood Branded: A marketing-focused blog that may have a vested interest in promoting Rae's career, potentially leading to biased reporting 7.

Conflicts of Interest

Some sources, particularly those with a marketing or promotional angle, may have conflicts of interest that could influence their portrayal of Rae's music. For example, blogs that focus on branding and celebrity culture may present a more favorable view of Rae's work to align with promotional efforts.

Methodology and Evidence

The claim about Rae's newer songs being "flops" lacks empirical evidence. To evaluate this assertion, metrics such as streaming counts, chart positions, and critical reviews of her subsequent releases would be necessary. Additionally, understanding the context of the music industry, where success can be measured in various ways, would provide a clearer picture.

4. Conclusion

Verdict: Partially True

The claim that "Diet Pepsi" is a successful release for Addison Rae is supported by substantial evidence, including positive critical reception and comparisons to established artists. However, the assertion that her newer songs are "flops" is vague and lacks specific metrics or details regarding which songs are being referenced. Without clear evidence to substantiate the claim of failure for her subsequent releases, it remains uncertain.

It is important to note that the definition of a "flop" can vary widely depending on individual perspectives and industry standards. The lack of concrete data on Rae's newer songs limits the ability to fully assess their performance. Readers should approach such claims with a critical mindset, considering the nuances of success in the music industry and the subjective nature of music reception.

As always, it is advisable for readers to evaluate information critically and seek out comprehensive evidence before forming conclusions.

5. Sources

1. Diet Pepsi (song) - Wikipedia. Link
2. Single Review: Addison Rae - Diet Pepsi | Redbrick Music. Link
3. Addison Rae - Diet Pepsi (Official Video). Link
4. Addison Rae Is Sweet Like 'Diet Pepsi' on Major Label Debut - Rolling Stone. Link
5. My guilty pleasure: Addison Rae's 'Diet Pepsi'. Link
6. Review of Diet Pepsi by k_k. Link
7. Addison Rae's Music Rebrand: How 'Diet Pepsi' Silenced the Critics. Link
8. Addison Rae's 'Diet Pepsi' is surprisingly refreshing - Punkee. Link
9. Addison Rae's "Diet Pepsi" Review: Super-Sweet Seedy. Link
10. Addison Rae's 'Diet Pepsi' & More Cool New Pop Songs. Link