Fact Check: Did Sonic Chronicle game is considered as non canon ?

Fact Check: Is Sonic Chronicles Considered Non-Canon?

What We Know

"Sonic Chronicles: The Dark Brotherhood" is a role-playing video game developed by BioWare and published by Sega, released in 2008. It is notable for being the only RPG entry in the Sonic the Hedgehog series. The game follows Sonic and his friends as they attempt to rescue Knuckles and recover the stolen Chaos Emeralds, introducing new characters and story elements, including the Nocturnus Clan and Shade the Echidna (source-1).

The canonicity of "Sonic Chronicles" has been a topic of debate among fans. Some sources, including the "Sonic the Hedgehog Encyclo-speed-ia," explicitly state that the game is considered non-canon due to its inconsistencies with the established Sonic timeline and the lack of a sequel to resolve its cliffhanger ending (source-1, source-7). Conversely, other discussions within the fan community argue that the game was intended to fit within the Sonic universe and that its story could be interpreted as canonical despite the absence of a direct sequel (source-2, source-4).

Analysis

The debate over the canonicity of "Sonic Chronicles" hinges on several factors:

1. Timeline Placement: Critics argue that the game cannot be reconciled with the broader Sonic timeline, as it introduces characters and plot points that do not align with other entries in the series. However, supporters claim that many Sonic games have similar issues, and that "Chronicles" was meant to be a continuation of the series (source-2).

2. Character Consistency: Some fans point out that character portrayals in "Chronicles" differ from those in other games, suggesting a lack of continuity. However, it is also noted that character inconsistencies are common across the Sonic franchise, which complicates the argument for declaring "Chronicles" non-canon based solely on character behavior (source-2).

3. Official Statements: The "Sonic the Hedgehog Encyclo-speed-ia" categorically states that "Sonic Chronicles" is non-canon, which carries weight in the discussion. However, the absence of an official statement from Sega or Sonic Team regarding its canonicity leaves room for interpretation (source-1, source-6).

4. Community Perspectives: The fan community is divided, with some arguing for the game's inclusion in the canon based on its narrative and character development, while others cite its lack of resolution and integration into the larger series as reasons for its exclusion (source-2, source-4).

Conclusion

The claim that "Sonic Chronicles" is considered non-canon is Partially True. While official sources and some community discussions assert that the game does not fit within the established Sonic timeline and is thus non-canonical, there are also arguments that it was intended to be part of the series. The lack of a sequel and the game's inconsistencies contribute to the ongoing debate, making it a complex issue within the Sonic fandom.

Sources

1. Sonic Chronicles: The Dark Brotherhood
2. The canonicity of Chronicles - Sonic Chat
3. Sonic Chronicles is not Canon | Fandom
4. How Canon Is Chronicles? - Games
5. Does Sonic have a canon timeline? - Games Learning Society
6. Sonic Chronicles: The Dark Brotherhood
7. Semi Frequent Sonic Facts - X
8. That settles it. This game isn't canon... Spoilers - Sonic ...