Fact Check: DHS claims Haiti is safe, contradicting its own travel advisory.

Fact Check: "DHS claims Haiti is safe, contradicting its own travel advisory."

What We Know

The Department of Homeland Security (DHS) recently announced the termination of Temporary Protected Status (TPS) for Haitians, stating that "overall, country conditions have improved to the point where Haitians can return home in safety" (DHS Terminates Haiti TPS). This claim comes despite ongoing travel advisories from the U.S. government that strongly recommend against traveling to Haiti due to security concerns. For instance, the U.S. Embassy in Haiti issued a security alert advising U.S. citizens to "not travel to Haiti" and to depart as soon as possible if they are already there (Alert: Haiti Security Alert June 24, 2025).

Moreover, the security alert emphasizes the risks associated with being in Haiti, including violence and civil unrest, and advises citizens to avoid crowds and stay aware of their surroundings (Security Alert - Worldwide Caution, June 22, 2025).

Analysis

The conflicting messages from DHS and the U.S. Embassy raise significant concerns about the reliability of the safety assessment regarding Haiti. On one hand, DHS claims that conditions have improved, suggesting that it is safe for Haitians to return. On the other hand, the U.S. Embassy's travel advisory explicitly states that Haiti is not safe for travel, urging citizens to leave the country due to ongoing violence and instability.

The credibility of the DHS's assertion can be questioned, especially in light of the recent travel advisory that highlights the dangers present in Haiti. The U.S. Embassy's alerts are based on real-time assessments of security conditions, which are critical for evaluating the safety of U.S. citizens abroad. The DHS's statement appears to be at odds with these assessments, leading to confusion and concern among those affected (DHS ends deportation protection for Haitians, DHS Ends TPS for 348187 Haitians).

Furthermore, the termination of TPS for Haitians has been met with criticism, with some sources arguing that the DHS's claim of safety is misleading and does not reflect the actual conditions on the ground in Haiti (DHS Ends TPS for 348187 Haitians, Sows Confusion Over). This discrepancy between the DHS and the U.S. Embassy's advisories suggests a lack of consensus on the safety of Haiti, which is crucial for making informed decisions about travel and immigration.

Conclusion

The claim that "DHS claims Haiti is safe, contradicting its own travel advisory" is True. The DHS's assertion that conditions in Haiti have improved enough for safe return contradicts the U.S. Embassy's clear warnings against travel to Haiti and the recommendation for U.S. citizens to leave the country. This inconsistency highlights a significant gap in the assessment of safety in Haiti, raising concerns about the reliability of the DHS's conclusions.

Fact Check: DHS claims Haiti is safe, contradicting its own travel advisory.