TruthOrFake Logo
TruthOrFake
Fact Check: Council democracy is the best democracy

Fact Check: Council democracy is the best democracy

Published March 11, 2025•Updated June 18, 2025
ByFactChecker 1.1 avatarFactChecker 1.1
±
VERDICT
Partially True

# Fact Check: "Council democracy is the best democracy" ## What We Know Council democracy, also known as Soviet democracy, is a political system root...

Fact Check: "Council democracy is the best democracy"

What We Know

Council democracy, also known as Soviet democracy, is a political system rooted in Marxist theory where governance is exercised through directly elected councils, or "soviets." These councils are accountable to their constituents and operate on a delegate model of representation, allowing for recall elections of delegates at any time (source-1). This system emphasizes direct participation and accountability, contrasting with the trustee model found in liberal democracies, where elected representatives act based on their judgment rather than direct mandates from their constituents.

Historically, council democracy has been associated with various socialist movements and has influenced anarchist-communist theorists who advocate for decentralized, grassroots governance (source-1). The concept gained renewed interest in the 21st century, particularly in the context of global movements advocating for direct democracy and political participation (source-2).

Analysis

The claim that "council democracy is the best democracy" is subjective and largely depends on the criteria used to define "best." Proponents argue that council democracy allows for greater direct participation and accountability than traditional liberal democracies. They highlight its potential to empower ordinary citizens and foster a more engaged political culture (source-2).

However, critics point out that historical implementations of council democracy, particularly in the Soviet Union, were often marred by authoritarianism and repression. The totalitarian model of Soviet governance has been criticized for undermining the very democratic principles it purported to uphold (source-1). Scholars argue that while the idea of council democracy is appealing, its practical applications have often led to a concentration of power rather than the intended decentralization (source-1).

Additionally, the revival of interest in council democracy in contemporary political theory raises questions about its feasibility and effectiveness in modern contexts. Some theorists suggest that while council democracy offers valuable insights into participatory governance, it may not be a panacea for the challenges facing current democratic systems (source-2).

Conclusion

The assertion that "council democracy is the best democracy" is Partially True. While council democracy presents a compelling model for enhancing direct participation and accountability in governance, its historical applications have often deviated from these ideals, leading to authoritarian practices. The effectiveness of council democracy as a superior form of governance remains a subject of debate, influenced by both theoretical perspectives and historical experiences.

Sources

  1. Soviet democracy - Wikipedia
  2. (PDF) Reviving Council Democracy for Modern Politics - Academia.edu
  3. Types of democracy
  4. (PDF) Council Democracy: Towards a Democratic Socialist Politics
  5. (PDF) Council Democracy - David Ellerman
  6. Democracy | Definition, History, Meaning, Types, Examples
  7. A Theory of Council Democracy - SpringerLink
  8. Local Democracy

Have a claim you want to verify? It's 100% Free!

Our AI-powered fact-checker analyzes claims against thousands of reliable sources and provides evidence-based verdicts in seconds. Completely free with no registration required.

💡 Try:
"Coffee helps you live longer"
✓100% Free
✓No Registration
✓Instant Results

Comments

Leave a comment

Loading comments...

More Fact Checks to Explore

Discover similar claims and stay informed with these related fact-checks

🔍
Partially True
🎯 Similar

Fact Check: Transcript 00:00 For all of their strutting about protesting that they support democracy. Not a one of them gave a damn about democracy when they pulled Biden off the ballot and dropped Kamala Harris in without a single Democrat primary voter voting for him. And you know what? Not a single Democrat is here today because not a single one of them gives a damn about the fact that they lied to the American people for four years. They knew Every one of them knew that Joe Biden was 00:34 mentally not competent to do the job. The White House Press Secretary. She knew when she stood in front of the American people and lied over and over and over again and they're not here because they can't defend themselves. It wasn't a surprise for four years the White House hid President Biden from Republican Senators. Would not let him meet with us. He served 40 years in this body. We all know him. And they deliberately lied and by the way Jake Tapper had a bombshell 01:08 book exposing the incredible scandal that Biden's mental decline was covered up by Jake Tapper. There's a Yiddish word and that truly is how dare we lie and cover up what we all knew. Now I have been asked literally a thousand times by Texans. Was running the country? And I'm going to give 01:40 you the most terrifying answer. I don't know. I genuinely don't know. And not a single Democrat here cares. The most telling proof of Biden's decline came with the signature of the president. The symbol of executive authority that was outsourced to a machine. Mister Wald you're a lawyer who served in the White House Council's Office. You understand the gravity of presidential action. Does the president's signature 02:10 carry legal and constitutional weight under article two? Yes. Is the act of signing an executive order or signing a law or granting a pardon a delegable duty of the president. Uh so in that opinion in 2005 from OLC they said essentially that an autopin could be used by a subordinate but the president's determination as to sign the document can never be delegated. Can that authority 02:41 be transferred to a staff or a machine without the president's explicit authorization? Never. And if you look at the statistics, the statistics are stunning. In 2021, President Biden issued 78 executive orders. None were signed with an auto pen. That first year the presidency, Biden I suppose was relatively lucid and 78 executive orders he signed by hand. The second year, however, we see the auto pen emerged. 03:15 The first auto pen executive order was issued on 15th 2022. After that day 100% of the executive orders issued in 2022 were signed by an autopen. In 2023 Biden issued twenty-four executive orders. 16 were auto penned. In 20twenty-four Biden issued 19. 14 were auto penned. In twenty twenty-5 Biden issued fourteen executive orders every single one was auto pins. 03:52 Mister Wald let me ask you as a legal matter if there's a law that's passed both houses of Congress and it goes to the White House and a staffer autopins signing that law without the president's authorization is that law legally passed and signed in the law? No. If an executive order is issued and a staffer autopins it without the president's authorization, is that executive order legally binding? No. And if a pardon issued from the President of 04:22 the United States and a staffer auto pens it without the president's authorization. Is that pardon legally binding? No. Under the Biden White House the ceremonial song hailed to the chief was effectively replaced with hail to the pen and it was an outright assault on democracy and every reporter covering this ought to ask why doesn't a Democrat care? We heard about the moral responsibilities of a staffer. 04:54 How about an elected senator who knows damn well that if we get into a war and Iran is preparing to fire a nuclear weapon at the United States that the commander in chief is busy playing with his jello and he's not competent to defend ourselves and every member of the cabinet, the chief of staff, the press secretary, and the members of Congress who lied about this on a daily basis with the press's complicity. They are all responsible for subverting democracy. Angry Ted Cruz is perhaps my favorite version of 05:27 Ted Cruz because when he's getting history on it, you might want to take a listen. He is definitely angry that there's some acting going on here in the line of hail to the chief change from hail to the pen that's not a smart line but it's still the truth. The truth is in this video right here ladies and gentlemen. The change in the way Joe Biden used the autopin is a steady upward moving graph from twenty twenty-one to the end of his presidency in early twenty 05:58 twenty-five. Okay? That is a noticeable issue. And if he does not directly authorize the autopin we've got We've got grounds to go through every single law Joe Biden has signed that way and perhaps ignore them all together. There's way more evidence behind the autopin theory and hopefully it ends up sticking. I I hope it does because I think this is in a way worse than the Bill Clinton perjury case. Cuz Bill 06:28 Clinton basically lied before Congress lied directly to the American people lied under oath. This is worse in a way. Because lying under oath means that you know where the truth is and you're just hoping to get away with it and there's a direct law. This however Signing with the auto pin is more opaque. It is an ultimate he said she said and you're dont rate the opinion oo just fact if there is

Detailed fact-check analysis of: Transcript 00:00 For all of their strutting about protesting that they support democracy. Not a one of them gave a damn about democracy when they pulled Biden off the ballot and dropped Kamala Harris in without a single Democrat primary voter voting for him. And you know what? Not a single Democrat is here today because not a single one of them gives a damn about the fact that they lied to the American people for four years. They knew Every one of them knew that Joe Biden was 00:34 mentally not competent to do the job. The White House Press Secretary. She knew when she stood in front of the American people and lied over and over and over again and they're not here because they can't defend themselves. It wasn't a surprise for four years the White House hid President Biden from Republican Senators. Would not let him meet with us. He served 40 years in this body. We all know him. And they deliberately lied and by the way Jake Tapper had a bombshell 01:08 book exposing the incredible scandal that Biden's mental decline was covered up by Jake Tapper. There's a Yiddish word and that truly is how dare we lie and cover up what we all knew. Now I have been asked literally a thousand times by Texans. Was running the country? And I'm going to give 01:40 you the most terrifying answer. I don't know. I genuinely don't know. And not a single Democrat here cares. The most telling proof of Biden's decline came with the signature of the president. The symbol of executive authority that was outsourced to a machine. Mister Wald you're a lawyer who served in the White House Council's Office. You understand the gravity of presidential action. Does the president's signature 02:10 carry legal and constitutional weight under article two? Yes. Is the act of signing an executive order or signing a law or granting a pardon a delegable duty of the president. Uh so in that opinion in 2005 from OLC they said essentially that an autopin could be used by a subordinate but the president's determination as to sign the document can never be delegated. Can that authority 02:41 be transferred to a staff or a machine without the president's explicit authorization? Never. And if you look at the statistics, the statistics are stunning. In 2021, President Biden issued 78 executive orders. None were signed with an auto pen. That first year the presidency, Biden I suppose was relatively lucid and 78 executive orders he signed by hand. The second year, however, we see the auto pen emerged. 03:15 The first auto pen executive order was issued on 15th 2022. After that day 100% of the executive orders issued in 2022 were signed by an autopen. In 2023 Biden issued twenty-four executive orders. 16 were auto penned. In 20twenty-four Biden issued 19. 14 were auto penned. In twenty twenty-5 Biden issued fourteen executive orders every single one was auto pins. 03:52 Mister Wald let me ask you as a legal matter if there's a law that's passed both houses of Congress and it goes to the White House and a staffer autopins signing that law without the president's authorization is that law legally passed and signed in the law? No. If an executive order is issued and a staffer autopins it without the president's authorization, is that executive order legally binding? No. And if a pardon issued from the President of 04:22 the United States and a staffer auto pens it without the president's authorization. Is that pardon legally binding? No. Under the Biden White House the ceremonial song hailed to the chief was effectively replaced with hail to the pen and it was an outright assault on democracy and every reporter covering this ought to ask why doesn't a Democrat care? We heard about the moral responsibilities of a staffer. 04:54 How about an elected senator who knows damn well that if we get into a war and Iran is preparing to fire a nuclear weapon at the United States that the commander in chief is busy playing with his jello and he's not competent to defend ourselves and every member of the cabinet, the chief of staff, the press secretary, and the members of Congress who lied about this on a daily basis with the press's complicity. They are all responsible for subverting democracy. Angry Ted Cruz is perhaps my favorite version of 05:27 Ted Cruz because when he's getting history on it, you might want to take a listen. He is definitely angry that there's some acting going on here in the line of hail to the chief change from hail to the pen that's not a smart line but it's still the truth. The truth is in this video right here ladies and gentlemen. The change in the way Joe Biden used the autopin is a steady upward moving graph from twenty twenty-one to the end of his presidency in early twenty 05:58 twenty-five. Okay? That is a noticeable issue. And if he does not directly authorize the autopin we've got We've got grounds to go through every single law Joe Biden has signed that way and perhaps ignore them all together. There's way more evidence behind the autopin theory and hopefully it ends up sticking. I I hope it does because I think this is in a way worse than the Bill Clinton perjury case. Cuz Bill 06:28 Clinton basically lied before Congress lied directly to the American people lied under oath. This is worse in a way. Because lying under oath means that you know where the truth is and you're just hoping to get away with it and there's a direct law. This however Signing with the auto pin is more opaque. It is an ultimate he said she said and you're dont rate the opinion oo just fact if there is

Jul 27, 2025
Read more →
Fact Check: Denver City Council ended car theft tracking to protect illegal immigrants.
Partially True
🎯 Similar

Fact Check: Denver City Council ended car theft tracking to protect illegal immigrants.

Detailed fact-check analysis of: Denver City Council ended car theft tracking to protect illegal immigrants.

Jul 8, 2025
Read more →
Fact Check: Council slammed with demands to ban Bob Vylan from Boardmasters
Unverified
🎯 Similar

Fact Check: Council slammed with demands to ban Bob Vylan from Boardmasters

Detailed fact-check analysis of: Council slammed with demands to ban Bob Vylan from Boardmasters

Jul 30, 2025
Read more →
Fact Check: The Toronto Zoo lost its AZA accredidation after city council voted to move its elephants to a California sanctuary.
True

Fact Check: The Toronto Zoo lost its AZA accredidation after city council voted to move its elephants to a California sanctuary.

Detailed fact-check analysis of: The Toronto Zoo lost its AZA accredidation after city council voted to move its elephants to a California sanctuary.

Jul 9, 2025
Read more →
Fact Check: The Homeland Security Advisory Council provides advice on homeland security operations.
True

Fact Check: The Homeland Security Advisory Council provides advice on homeland security operations.

Detailed fact-check analysis of: The Homeland Security Advisory Council provides advice on homeland security operations.

Jul 3, 2025
Read more →
🔍
Unverified

Fact Check: The United Nations Security Council has 15 member states.

Detailed fact-check analysis of: The United Nations Security Council has 15 member states.

Jul 2, 2025
Read more →
Explore All Fact Checks