Fact Check: Chad Hartmann Reports 20% Drop in Production Due to Immigration Raid
What We Know
On September 20, 2023, an immigration raid conducted by U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) at Glenn Valley Foods in Omaha resulted in the detention of approximately 74 to 76 workers out of a total workforce of around 140 (Reuters) [source-1]. Chad Hartmann, the president of Glenn Valley Foods, expressed that the raid left the company in a state of confusion and fear, particularly among the remaining employees (AP News) [source-2]. Hartmann reported a significant impact on production, stating that the trauma and fear among employees led to a 20% drop in production following the raid (NBC News) [source-5].
Analysis
The claim that Chad Hartmann reported a 20% drop in production due to fear and trauma among employees is supported by his own statements following the raid. Hartmann described the emotional and operational turmoil that ensued after the raid, indicating that the remaining staff were significantly affected by the events (NBC News) [source-5].
However, while Hartmann's assertion about the production drop is credible, it is important to note that the specific percentage he cited (20%) has not been independently verified by external sources. The reports primarily focus on the number of detained employees and the immediate aftermath of the raid rather than quantifying the exact impact on production (Reuters) [source-1], (AP News) [source-2].
Additionally, the context of the raid itself is crucial. The operation was part of a broader enforcement action targeting the employment of unauthorized workers, which has historically created an atmosphere of fear in immigrant communities (NBC News) [source-5]. The emotional toll on employees in such situations can lead to decreased productivity, but quantifying this impact precisely is inherently challenging.
The sources reporting on this incident are generally reliable, with major news organizations like Reuters, AP News, and NBC News providing coverage. However, the lack of independent confirmation of the 20% figure means that while the claim is plausible, it cannot be fully substantiated.
Conclusion
Verdict: Partially True
Chad Hartmann's statement regarding a 20% drop in production due to fear and trauma among remaining employees following the immigration raid at Glenn Valley Foods is plausible and aligns with the emotional and operational disruptions reported. However, the specific percentage has not been independently verified, leading to a conclusion that the claim is partially true.
