Fact Check: "Canadian citizen dies in ICE custody under mysterious circumstances"
What We Know
On June 23, 2025, Johnny Noviello, a 49-year-old Canadian citizen, died while in the custody of U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) at a detention center in Miami, Florida. The cause of death remains under investigation, as confirmed by ICE and various news outlets (CBC, Newsweek). Noviello had been detained by ICE since May 15, 2025, following his conviction for serious offenses, including racketeering and drug trafficking, for which he received a 12-month prison sentence (ICE, HuffPost).
Noviello's lawyer described him as a "very polite, quiet, unassuming man" who did not pose a danger to anyone, and emphasized that he had not violated the terms of his probation prior to his arrest by ICE (CBC). Concerns were raised about his access to medication for epilepsy during his detention, although it remains unclear whether he received the necessary treatment (CBC).
Analysis
The claim that a Canadian citizen died in ICE custody under "mysterious circumstances" is supported by the fact that the cause of death is still unknown and under investigation. However, the term "mysterious" could imply a level of suspicion or wrongdoing that is not substantiated by the available evidence. While it is true that Noviello's death raises questions about the conditions in ICE facilities, particularly regarding medical care, ICE has stated that it provides comprehensive medical services to detainees (Newsweek).
The reliability of the sources varies. CBC, as a national broadcaster, is generally considered credible, providing detailed accounts from family members and legal representatives (CBC). Newsweek also offers a thorough report, citing ICE's official statements and the ongoing investigation (Newsweek). However, some sources, such as Checkforme, may have a more sensationalist approach, which could skew the perception of the events (Checkforme).
Conclusion
The claim that a Canadian citizen died in ICE custody under mysterious circumstances is Partially True. While it is accurate that Johnny Noviello died in custody and that the cause of death is under investigation, the use of the term "mysterious" may suggest an implication of foul play or negligence that is not yet substantiated by evidence. The ongoing investigation will likely provide more clarity on the circumstances surrounding his death.
Sources
- Canadian national in ICE custody passes away
- Canadian who died in ICE custody lived a 'simple life,' his ... - CBC.ca
- Canadian National Dies in ICE Custody: What We Know
- Canada Seeks Answers To U.S Resident's Death In ICE Custody - HuffPost
- Canada demands answers after a citizen dies in ICE custody - Axios
- Mysterious Death in ICE Custody: Canadian Man Becomes 10th Victim This ...
