Fact Check: California Governor Newsom suffers major legal defeat over Trump's National Guard control.

Fact Check: California Governor Newsom Suffers Major Legal Defeat Over Trump's National Guard Control

What We Know

A recent ruling by the 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals has confirmed that President Trump can maintain control over California National Guard troops deployed in Los Angeles, effectively blocking Governor Gavin Newsom's attempts to regain control. This ruling came after a lower court had previously determined that Trump's deployment was illegal, citing violations of the Tenth Amendment and exceeding his statutory authority (NPR). The appeals court's decision is temporary but indicates a significant legal setback for Newsom, who argued that Trump's actions were unlawful and that the military presence could escalate tensions during ongoing protests against federal immigration policies (AP News).

Analysis

The appeals court's ruling has been described as a "major legal defeat" for Governor Newsom, as it allows Trump to maintain federal control over the National Guard troops in a situation that has raised constitutional questions about the balance of power between state and federal authorities. The court noted that the president has the authority to deploy the National Guard to prevent interference with federal law enforcement, which was a key argument in Trump's defense (NPR).

Critically, the ruling also highlighted that while the appeals court disagreed with the lower court's assessment that the protests did not constitute a rebellion, it maintained that courts should defer to the president's decisions regarding troop deployment. This deference raises concerns about judicial oversight in matters of military engagement and civil unrest, particularly when state governors oppose such actions (AP News).

The source reliability for this analysis is strong, as it is based on official court rulings and statements from both the Trump administration and Governor Newsom. However, there is potential bias in the portrayal of events, particularly in how different news outlets frame the conflict between state and federal authority.

Conclusion

The claim that "California Governor Newsom suffers major legal defeat over Trump's National Guard control" is True. The appeals court's ruling effectively allows Trump to maintain control over the National Guard troops in Los Angeles, contradicting the earlier decision by a federal district judge. This legal outcome underscores the complexities of federalism in the United States, particularly regarding the deployment of military forces in domestic situations.

Fact Check: California Governor Newsom suffers major legal defeat over Trump's National Guard control.