Fact Check: Ben Sulayem's Changes to FIA Rules Consolidate Power and Weaken Oversight
What We Know
Mohammed Ben Sulayem has been the president of the FIA (Fédération Internationale de l'Automobile) since December 2021. Recently, he made significant changes to the FIA's governance structure, including the removal of Britain's representative on the FIA Senate, Ben Cussons, and his replacement with Anar Alakbarov, a known ally of Ben Sulayem (source-1). This change occurred shortly after amendments to the FIA statutes were voted through, which granted the president the authority to appoint or dismiss four "independent and qualified" members of the Senate without needing confirmation from the other members, a shift from the previous requirement for majority approval (source-2).
Critics argue that these changes are a clear attempt to consolidate power in Ben Sulayem's hands and weaken the oversight capabilities of the Senate, which is responsible for financial governance and oversight within the FIA (source-3). The Austrian national motoring club, OAMTC, has publicly criticized these amendments, stating they contribute to a "dark period of democratic backsliding" within the FIA (source-4).
Analysis
The claim that Ben Sulayem's changes consolidate power and weaken oversight is supported by several pieces of evidence. The removal of Cussons, who had been a supporter of Ben Sulayem, and the appointment of Alakbarov, who is perceived as an ally, raises questions about the motivations behind these changes. Cussons himself expressed surprise at his dismissal and noted a lack of communication regarding the reasons for his removal, emphasizing a desire for transparency (source-1).
Moreover, the amendments to the FIA statutes have been criticized for centralizing decision-making power within the presidency. The OAMTC's letter to the FIA World Council highlighted concerns that these changes would erode the FIA's reputation for competent governance and reduce the independence of oversight bodies (source-5). The amendments were passed with a significant majority, but the process has been described as lacking proper review and discussion, further fueling allegations of undemocratic practices (source-6).
However, the FIA has defended these changes as necessary for operational flexibility and improvement, arguing that they are in line with democratic processes as they were voted through by a supermajority of member clubs (source-2). This defense suggests that while the changes may appear to consolidate power, they were enacted through a legitimate voting process.
Conclusion
The claim that Ben Sulayem's changes to FIA rules consolidate power and weaken oversight is Partially True. While the amendments and the removal of key figures do suggest a shift towards greater presidential control and a potential reduction in oversight, the changes were enacted through a democratic process, albeit one criticized for its lack of transparency and inclusiveness. The concerns raised by critics highlight significant issues regarding governance and oversight within the FIA, warranting further scrutiny.
Sources
- Ben Sulayem removes Britain's senate representative
- FIA: Controversial statute changes voted through
- Ben Sulayem removes Britain's senate representative
- Mohammed Ben Sulayem scores political points as FIA ...
- New attack on Ben Sulayem plans warns of 'dark period' for ...
- FIA controversial governance changes voted through