Fact Check: "Attack occurred on subway after phone request was declined"
What We Know
On June 20, 2025, a woman and her 11-month-old daughter were pepper-sprayed on a subway train in Queens, New York. The incident occurred after the woman declined a stranger's request to use her phone while they were waiting for the train on the platform. Following this refusal, the man allegedly attacked her as the train approached the Court Square-23rd Street station (NBC New York). The victims were taken to a hospital for evaluation and were reported to be in stable condition (NBC New York).
Analysis
The claim that the attack occurred after the woman declined a phone request is supported by multiple sources. NBC New York reported that the attacker had asked to use the woman's phone before the assault took place (NBC New York). Additionally, a fact-checking article corroborated this information, stating that the attack happened shortly after the woman refused the request (Truth or Fake).
Both sources are credible, with NBC New York being a well-established news outlet and the fact-checking site providing a detailed account of the incident. The consistency in the reports strengthens the reliability of the claim. There are no conflicting reports that dispute the sequence of events leading to the attack.
Conclusion
Verdict: True. The evidence clearly supports the claim that the attack on the subway occurred after the woman declined a request to use her phone. The details provided by multiple reliable sources confirm the circumstances surrounding the incident.
