Are XQD Cards Discontinued?
The claim that XQD memory cards have been discontinued has circulated in various tech circles, particularly following announcements from manufacturers and distributors. This article aims to dissect the available evidence surrounding the status of XQD cards, examining the reliability of sources and the context of the claims made.
What We Know
-
Lexar's Discontinuation Announcement: In late 2018, Lexar, which had undergone ownership changes, announced it would no longer support the XQD format, favoring CFexpress instead. This decision was attributed to various issues, including market demand and production challenges 1.
-
Current Availability: Despite the discontinuation announcement from Lexar, some reports suggest that XQD cards are still being produced and sold. For instance, a blog post from Vtech Insider claims that while Lexar has stopped making XQD cards, existing stock remains available for purchase 23.
-
Manufacturer Responses: In response to rumors about discontinuation, Lexar had previously assured customers that it would continue producing XQD cards to meet existing demand, particularly for high-end Nikon DSLRs 5. However, subsequent reports indicate that Lexar has shifted its focus away from XQD to CFexpress 4.
-
Sony's Role: Sony is a key player in the XQD market, producing XQD memory cards that are marketed as robust and high-speed options 7. However, there is limited information on Sony's future plans for XQD cards, which complicates the overall picture.
-
Community Insights: Discussions in photography forums suggest uncertainty about the future of XQD cards, with some users expressing skepticism about their viability in the face of CFexpress's growing popularity 6.
Analysis
The evidence surrounding the discontinuation of XQD cards is mixed and warrants careful scrutiny:
-
Source Reliability:
- Wikipedia 1 is generally a reliable starting point for information but should be cross-referenced with more authoritative sources, especially for claims about corporate decisions.
- Vtech Insider 23 presents a narrative that aligns with the discontinuation claim but lacks citations from primary sources or industry experts, raising questions about its reliability.
- DIY Photography 4 provides a timeline of Lexar's announcements and responses, which adds context but may reflect a bias towards sensationalism in tech reporting.
-
Conflicts of Interest:
- Lexar's statements, particularly in response to rumors, may be influenced by their business interests in maintaining customer confidence in their products. This could lead to potential biases in their communications.
-
Methodology:
- Many sources rely on anecdotal evidence or community discussions rather than comprehensive market analysis or official statements from all manufacturers involved, which limits the robustness of their claims.
-
Contradicting Evidence:
- Some sources, such as forum discussions 6, suggest that while XQD cards may be less popular, they are not entirely obsolete. This contradicts the notion of a complete discontinuation and highlights the need for more nuanced understanding.
Conclusion
Verdict: Partially True
The claim that XQD cards have been discontinued is partially true. Evidence indicates that Lexar has ceased production of XQD cards, citing market demand and a shift towards CFexpress. However, reports suggest that existing stock of XQD cards remains available, and Sony continues to produce them, albeit with unclear future plans. This mixed evidence leads to uncertainty regarding the complete discontinuation of the XQD format.
It is important to note that the situation is fluid, with varying reports from different sources and a lack of comprehensive data from all manufacturers involved. The reliance on anecdotal evidence and community discussions further complicates the picture, making it difficult to draw definitive conclusions.
Readers are encouraged to critically evaluate information and consider the nuances in claims regarding technology products, especially in rapidly evolving markets like memory storage.
