Fact Check: Are VVS2 diamonds good?

Are VVS2 Diamonds Good?

The claim regarding VVS2 diamonds centers on their quality and desirability as gemstones. VVS2, which stands for "Very Very Slightly Included," is a clarity grade in the diamond grading system. The question of whether VVS2 diamonds are "good" involves considerations of their clarity, visual appeal, and value relative to other diamonds.

What We Know

1. Clarity Definition: VVS2 diamonds have inclusions that are very difficult to detect, even under magnification. According to the Gemological Institute of America (GIA), VVS2 diamonds contain minute inclusions that can be seen only by a skilled grader using 10x magnification 18.

2. Comparison with Other Grades: VVS2 diamonds are considered superior to VS (Very Slightly Included) diamonds, which have more noticeable inclusions. The difference between VVS1 and VVS2 is subtle, with VVS1 being slightly clearer 23. Both grades are generally regarded as "eye-clean," meaning that inclusions are not visible to the naked eye 35.

3. Market Position: VVS2 diamonds are positioned at the higher end of the clarity scale. They are often recommended for those seeking a balance between clarity and budget, as they allow buyers to allocate funds to other quality factors like cut and carat weight 45.

4. Consumer Recommendations: Various sources suggest that VVS2 diamonds can be a good choice for larger or fancy-shaped diamonds, as their clarity allows for a visually appealing stone without the premium price tag of VVS1 diamonds 46.

5. Value Considerations: While VVS2 diamonds are high in clarity, some experts argue that they may not always represent the best value for money. The recommendation is to ensure that other quality factors are also considered to achieve a balanced purchase 510.

Analysis

The sources consulted provide a range of perspectives on VVS2 diamonds, but they also exhibit some variability in their recommendations and conclusions:

• Credibility of Sources: The GIA is a highly reputable organization in the field of gemology, and its definitions and grading standards are widely accepted 1. Other sources like Brilliant Earth and The Diamond Pro also have established credibility in the diamond retail market, though they may have a vested interest in promoting higher clarity diamonds due to their potential for higher sales 23.

• Potential Bias: Retailers and educational sites may have an inherent bias towards promoting higher clarity diamonds, including VVS2, as these often command higher prices. This could influence the objectivity of their assessments regarding value and desirability 25.

• Methodology: The assessments of VVS2 diamonds are primarily based on clarity grading and visual appeal, but they lack detailed empirical studies comparing consumer satisfaction or long-term value retention of VVS2 diamonds against other grades. More comprehensive market analysis could provide deeper insights into consumer preferences and resale values.

• Conflicting Information: While many sources agree on the high quality of VVS2 diamonds, there are differing opinions on their value relative to other grades. Some suggest that buyers might get better value from diamonds with slightly lower clarity grades if they prioritize other quality factors 45.

Conclusion

Verdict: True

The evidence supports the claim that VVS2 diamonds are considered good quality gemstones. They are characterized by their very slight inclusions, which are difficult to detect even under magnification, making them visually appealing and generally regarded as "eye-clean." The Gemological Institute of America (GIA) and other reputable sources affirm their high clarity and desirability, particularly for buyers seeking a balance between quality and price.

However, it is important to note that while VVS2 diamonds are high in clarity, some experts caution that they may not always represent the best value for money compared to diamonds with slightly lower clarity grades. Buyers are encouraged to consider other quality factors, such as cut and carat weight, to ensure a well-rounded purchase.

Additionally, the available evidence primarily consists of expert opinions and market assessments, which may be subject to bias, particularly from retailers. There is a lack of comprehensive empirical studies that directly compare consumer satisfaction or long-term value retention of VVS2 diamonds against other grades. Therefore, while the claim holds true, potential buyers should critically evaluate their options and consider their individual preferences and budget.

Readers are reminded to approach information critically and to conduct their own research when making purchasing decisions regarding diamonds.

Sources

1. VVS vs. VS Diamonds | Diamond Clarity Differences. GIA. Available at: https://4cs.gia.edu/en-us/blog/vvs-diamond-versus-vs-diamond/
2. VVS Diamond Guide: Understanding VVS1 & VVS2 Clarity Differences. Brilliant Earth. Available at: https://www.brilliantearth.com/diamond/buying-guide/clarity/vvs/
3. VVS2 Diamond: Is it a Good Idea To Buy? - The Diamond Pro. Available at: https://www.diamonds.pro/education/vvs2-diamond/
4. VVS2 Diamond Clarity: A Guide to All You Need to Know. Learning Jewelry. Available at: https://learningjewelry.com/guides/buying-diamonds/diamond-clarity/vvs2-diamond/
5. A Complete Guide to VVS2 Clarity Diamonds | Whiteflash. Available at: https://www.whiteflash.com/diamond-education/diamond-clarity/vvs2-diamonds/
6. A Complete Guide to VVS2 Clarity Diamonds. Whiteflash. Available at: https://www.whiteflash.com/diamond-education/diamond-clarity/vvs2-diamonds/?srsltid=AfmBOoobkCY0UQsDbdU2fWn7I4kbNK_edArajUUQiCbvKxToQI5ZyIfv
7. VVS2 Diamond Clarity Explained [With Videos & Images]. Beyond 4Cs. Available at: https://beyond4cs.com/clarity/vvs2/
8. What Is A VVS2 Diamond Clarity Grade? Rockher. Available at: https://www.rockher.com/pages/what-is-a-vvs2-diamond-clarity-grade?srsltid=AfmBOor_TSaVU3TVZHTNzbEAKykZOfsRYTsYkc-D_JS_XsARZz_T2vi2
9. The Evolution of VVS Diamonds Grading Standards. Lightmark Jewelry. Available at: https://articles.lightmarkjewelry.com/evolution-vvs-diamonds-grading-standards/
10. Should I Buy a VVS2 Clarity Diamond? Gem Society. Available at: https://www.gemsociety.org/article/vvs2-clarity-guide/