Fact Check: Are VVS simulated diamonds real?

Are VVS Simulated Diamonds Real?

Introduction

The claim in question revolves around the nature of VVS simulated diamonds and whether they can be considered "real." VVS, which stands for "very, very small inclusions," typically refers to a grading of diamonds that indicates a high level of clarity. However, the term "simulated diamonds" suggests that these stones are not natural diamonds but rather man-made alternatives. This article explores the characteristics of VVS simulated diamonds, their comparison to natural diamonds, and the implications of their classification.

What We Know

1. Definition of Simulated Diamonds: Simulated diamonds are gemstones that visually resemble natural diamonds but differ in their chemical and physical properties. They are created through human intervention rather than geological processes 17.

2. VVS Grading: The term VVS indicates a clarity grade for diamonds, meaning they have very few inclusions that are difficult to detect under magnification. This grading can apply to both natural and lab-created diamonds, but the context of "simulated" implies that these stones are not genuine diamonds 9.

3. Durability and Value: Simulated diamonds, including VVS simulated diamonds, are generally less durable than natural diamonds. For instance, they may be more susceptible to scratching and have a lower resale value 36.

4. Consumer Perception: Many consumers find VVS simulated diamonds appealing due to their affordability and visual similarity to natural diamonds. However, they are not typically purchased for investment purposes 35.

5. Differences in Composition: Natural diamonds are formed over millions of years under high-pressure conditions, while VVS simulated diamonds are manufactured, often from materials like cubic zirconia or moissanite, which have different properties 24.

Analysis

The claim that VVS simulated diamonds are "real" hinges on the definition of "real." If "real" is interpreted as being a natural diamond, then VVS simulated diamonds do not qualify. However, if "real" refers to their visual appeal and market presence, then they may be considered "real" in a different context.

Source Evaluation

• GIA (Gemological Institute of America): The GIA is a reputable source in the gemological field, known for its educational resources and grading systems. Their information on simulated diamonds is credible and well-researched 1.

• Gempulses: This source provides an in-depth exploration of VVS simulated diamonds, but it lacks the same level of authority as GIA. While it offers useful insights, its reliability may be lessened due to potential bias in promoting simulated diamonds 2.

• Icecartel: This source discusses the appeal and drawbacks of VVS simulated diamonds. However, it may have a commercial interest in promoting these products, which could introduce bias 3.

• Jewelry Notes: This source provides practical advice on distinguishing simulated diamonds from real ones. Its focus on consumer education adds to its credibility, though it may still carry an implicit bias towards promoting natural diamonds 6.

• Brilliant Earth: This source distinguishes between simulated and lab-created diamonds, providing a clear understanding of the differences. It is a reputable retailer in the ethical jewelry space, but its commercial interests may influence its presentation of information 710.

Conflicts of Interest

Several sources, particularly those associated with jewelry retailers, may have a vested interest in promoting certain types of diamonds over others. This potential bias should be considered when evaluating their claims.

Methodological Concerns

There is a lack of comprehensive studies comparing the long-term durability and market perception of VVS simulated diamonds versus natural diamonds. More empirical data would enhance the understanding of consumer behavior and the actual performance of these stones over time.

Conclusion

Verdict: False

The claim that VVS simulated diamonds can be considered "real" diamonds is false when interpreted in the context of natural diamonds. VVS simulated diamonds are man-made alternatives that do not possess the same chemical and physical properties as natural diamonds. While they may visually resemble natural diamonds and appeal to consumers for their affordability, they lack the geological authenticity that defines a "real" diamond.

It is important to note that the term "real" can be subjective and context-dependent. In a broader sense, VVS simulated diamonds may be considered "real" in terms of their existence and market presence, but they do not meet the criteria of being natural diamonds.

Additionally, the available evidence is limited, particularly regarding consumer perceptions and the long-term performance of these stones compared to natural diamonds. More comprehensive studies would be beneficial in understanding the nuances of this topic.

Readers are encouraged to critically evaluate information and consider the definitions and contexts in which terms like "real" are used, especially in discussions surrounding gemstones and their classifications.

Sources

1. What Are Simulated Diamonds? | Diamond Simulants | GIA - GIA 4Cs
2. Understanding VVS Simulated Diamonds: An In-Depth Exploration
3. What Are VVS Simulated Diamonds: A Detailed Guide - Icecartel
4. Understanding VVS Diamonds: A Comprehensive Guide
5. Exploring VVS Diamond Simulates: Characteristics and Impact
6. Simulated vs. Real Diamonds: How to Tell the Difference - Jewelry Notes
7. What is a Simulated Diamond? Meaning & Lab Comparison Guide
8. Natural vs. Lab Created Diamond Rings
9. What is the difference between VVS, moissanite, CZ, and ...
10. What is a Simulated Diamond? Meaning & Lab Comparison Guide