Fact Check: Are QX80 good cars?

Are QX80 Good Cars?

The claim that "QX80s are good cars" invites scrutiny into the performance, reliability, and overall consumer satisfaction of the Infiniti QX80, a luxury SUV produced by Nissan's luxury division. This claim can be evaluated through various sources that provide insights into the vehicle's history, consumer reviews, and expert analyses.

What We Know

1. Reliability Ratings: The Infiniti QX80 has received mixed reliability ratings. According to MotorBiscuit, it is considered "pretty average" in terms of predicted reliability, with annual maintenance costs estimated at around $1,127 for full-size luxury SUVs, which is higher than the average for its category 4. However, Cars Counsel reports a more favorable reliability score of 3.5 out of 5, indicating above-average dependability and lower maintenance costs of approximately $718 annually 5.

2. Consumer Reviews: Consumer Reports provides a comprehensive review of the QX80, highlighting its performance, ride quality, and safety features, but also notes that some models score low in owner satisfaction 7. The 2022 model received positive feedback from 64% of owners, who rated it five out of five stars 10.

3. Best and Worst Years: According to Engine Patrol, the best model years for the QX80 are 2024, 2023, 2022, 2021, 2020, and 2018, while the worst years are 2014, 2019, 2015, 2016, and 2017. This assessment is based on auto industry reviews, National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) statistics, reported problems, and consumer feedback 2.

4. Expert Opinions: Edmunds praised the 2016 QX80 for its luxury, comfort, and technology, suggesting it is a solid pick among large luxury SUVs 3. In contrast, Consumer Reports' reviews of the 2025 model indicate it offers numerous comfort and convenience features but do not provide a definitive reliability score for this latest iteration 6.

Analysis

The evidence surrounding the Infiniti QX80's reputation as a "good car" is multifaceted and varies significantly based on model year and consumer experience.

• Source Reliability: Consumer Reports is generally regarded as a credible source due to its ad-free, influence-free model that relies on consumer feedback and expert testing 1. However, it is essential to note that while Consumer Reports provides valuable insights, it may not cover every aspect of consumer satisfaction, particularly subjective experiences.

• Bias and Conflicts of Interest: Websites like MotorBiscuit and Cars Counsel may have a vested interest in promoting certain vehicles, which could introduce bias into their assessments. Their ratings and reviews should be considered alongside independent evaluations to gain a more balanced perspective.

• Methodology Concerns: The assessments of the best and worst years for the QX80 rely on a combination of consumer feedback, expert reviews, and statistical data. However, the methodology behind these rankings is not always transparent, making it difficult to assess the validity of the conclusions drawn.

• Consumer Feedback: The mixed reviews from consumers indicate that while many owners appreciate the luxury and comfort of the QX80, others may have experienced issues that affect their overall satisfaction. This dichotomy suggests that individual experiences may vary widely based on personal expectations and specific vehicle conditions.

Conclusion

Verdict: Partially True

The claim that "QX80s are good cars" is partially true, as the evidence indicates a mix of positive and negative aspects regarding the Infiniti QX80. On one hand, certain model years, particularly recent ones, have garnered favorable reviews for their luxury, comfort, and performance, with some owners expressing high satisfaction. Conversely, reliability ratings are inconsistent, with some sources indicating average reliability and higher maintenance costs compared to competitors.

This verdict acknowledges the nuanced nature of the claim, as individual experiences with the QX80 can vary significantly based on model year and personal expectations. Additionally, the potential biases in some reviews and the lack of transparency in methodologies used to assess vehicle quality introduce uncertainty into the overall evaluation.

Readers are encouraged to critically evaluate information from multiple sources and consider their own needs and preferences when assessing the Infiniti QX80 or any vehicle.

Sources

1. Infiniti QX80 - Consumer Reports. Retrieved from Consumer Reports
2. 11 Best & Worst Infiniti QX80 Years (With Facts & Stats). Retrieved from Engine Patrol
3. 5 Best & Worst Infiniti QX80 Years (Stats & Examples). Retrieved from Motor & Wheels
4. How Reliable Is the Infiniti QX80? - MotorBiscuit.com. Retrieved from MotorBiscuit
5. Best and Worst Infiniti QX80 Years: What to Buy & Avoid. Retrieved from Cars Counsel
6. 2025 Infiniti QX80 Review - Consumer Reports. Retrieved from Consumer Reports
7. Infiniti Cars, & SUVs. Retrieved from Consumer Reports
8. 2025 Infiniti QX80 Reviews, Ratings, Prices - Consumer Reports. Retrieved from Consumer Reports
9. 2025 Infiniti QX80 Review, Pricing, & Pictures | U.S. News - Cars. Retrieved from U.S. News
10. 2022 INFINITI QX80 Consumer Reviews & Ratings. Retrieved from Kelley Blue Book