Fact Check: Are MQDs better than miles?

Are MQDs Better Than Miles?

Introduction

The claim under scrutiny is whether Medallion Qualification Dollars (MQDs) are better than traditional miles in the context of Delta Air Lines' SkyMiles program. This question arises from the complexities of airline loyalty programs, particularly how they reward frequent flyers and the benefits associated with different types of currency within these programs.

What We Know

1. Delta SkyMiles are the rewards currency that Delta Air Lines customers earn and redeem for flights. They can be used for free flights and upgrades on Delta and its partner airlines 16.

2. Medallion Qualification Dollars (MQDs) are a separate metric used to determine a member's eligibility for Medallion Status, which provides various benefits such as priority boarding and upgrades 57. MQDs are earned based on the amount spent on Delta flights, excluding taxes and fees.

3. The SkyMiles program underwent significant changes recently, making it more complicated for consumers to navigate the differences between these two forms of currency 12.

4. Earning MQDs is essential for achieving elite status within the SkyMiles program, which can enhance the travel experience through additional perks 45.

5. The value of MQDs versus SkyMiles can depend on individual travel habits and preferences. For example, frequent travelers may prioritize earning MQDs to achieve elite status, while occasional flyers may find more value in accumulating SkyMiles for free flights 39.

Analysis

The evaluation of whether MQDs are "better" than miles is inherently subjective and depends on the traveler's goals.

• Source Reliability: The sources cited include travel blogs and industry analysis sites. For instance, Thrifty Traveler and Slow Travel News provide straightforward explanations of the differences between MQDs and SkyMiles, but they may lack comprehensive data or independent analysis. These sources often cater to travelers seeking practical advice, which can introduce a bias toward simplifying complex topics for easier understanding 12.

• Conflicting Perspectives: Some sources, like U.S. News Travel and The Points Guy, offer broader comparisons of various airline loyalty programs, which may provide context for understanding how Delta's program stacks up against competitors 910. However, these sources also have a vested interest in promoting certain programs, which could color their analysis.

• Methodology Concerns: The methodologies used in evaluating loyalty programs vary significantly. For example, U.S. News evaluates programs based on earning and redemption values, which may not fully capture the qualitative aspects of loyalty programs, such as customer service or ease of earning status 10.

• Additional Information Needed: A more thorough analysis would benefit from empirical data comparing the actual redemption rates of MQDs versus SkyMiles, as well as user testimonials regarding their experiences with both. Additionally, insights from Delta Air Lines on how they calculate and value MQDs compared to SkyMiles would provide clarity.

Conclusion

Verdict: Unverified

The claim that MQDs are better than miles remains unverified due to the subjective nature of the evaluation and the lack of comprehensive, independent data. Key evidence includes the distinct purposes of MQDs and SkyMiles within Delta's loyalty program, where MQDs are essential for achieving elite status while SkyMiles are primarily used for redeeming flights. The complexity of the SkyMiles program and the varying travel habits of individuals further complicate any definitive comparison.

It is important to note that the assessment of "better" is highly dependent on individual preferences and travel patterns. Frequent travelers may find MQDs more beneficial for achieving elite status, while occasional flyers may prioritize accumulating SkyMiles for free flights. The sources consulted provide useful insights but may also reflect biases or lack rigorous analysis, highlighting the need for caution in drawing conclusions.

Moreover, the limitations of the available evidence, including the absence of empirical data comparing redemption rates and user experiences, reinforce the uncertainty surrounding this claim. Readers are encouraged to critically evaluate information regarding airline loyalty programs and consider their own travel needs when assessing the value of MQDs versus SkyMiles.

Sources

1. Thrifty Traveler. "Delta SkyMiles vs MQDs: What's the Difference?" Thrifty Traveler
2. Slow Travel News. "Delta SkyMiles vs MQDs: What's the Difference?" Slow Travel News
3. CB Travel. "The perks of loyalty: A comparison guide between major airline reward ..." CB Travel
4. Simple Flying. "The Different Tiers Of Delta Air Lines' SkyMiles Program." Simple Flying
5. Delta Air Lines. "SkyMiles Medallion Benefits." Delta Air Lines
6. Upgraded Points. "What Are the Differences Between Delta SkyMiles and ..." Upgraded Points
7. Delta Air Lines. "Medallion Program Overview." Delta Air Lines
8. Engage People. "How U.S. Airline Loyalty Programs Compare." Engage People
9. The Points Guy. "Best frequent flyer programs in the US for 2025." The Points Guy
10. U.S. News Travel. "Best Airline Rewards Programs for 2024-2025." U.S. News Travel