Fact Check: Are kaido and big mom dead?

Are Kaido and Big Mom Dead?

The claim regarding the fates of Kaido and Big Mom, two prominent characters in the manga and anime series One Piece, has sparked considerable debate among fans. Following their defeats in the Wano Country arc, questions have arisen about whether these characters are truly dead or if they may return in future storylines. This article will explore the available evidence and opinions surrounding this claim without reaching a definitive conclusion.

What We Know

1. Defeats in Wano Arc: Both Kaido and Big Mom were defeated during the Wano Country arc. Kaido was defeated by Luffy in chapter 1049, while Big Mom was taken down by Trafalgar Law and Eustass Kid in chapter 1040 35.

2. Speculation on Death: Some sources suggest that both characters are confirmed dead based on events in chapter 1053.2 of One Piece, which is part of the "Road to Laugh Tale" volume 5. However, this claim is contested, as other sources indicate that there has been no explicit confirmation of their deaths in the narrative 8.

3. Ongoing Discussions: The One Piece fandom is divided on the issue. Some fans believe that the narrative has hinted at the deaths of both characters, while others argue that the series is known for its "fake-out" deaths, suggesting that Kaido and Big Mom could return 9.

4. Lack of Clear Confirmation: As of chapter 1064, there has been no definitive statement regarding Kaido's fate, while Big Mom's status remains ambiguous 10. The narrative has left room for interpretation, which is common in long-running series like One Piece.

Analysis

The sources discussing the potential deaths of Kaido and Big Mom vary significantly in reliability and perspective:

• Animehunch and Attack of the Fanboy provide detailed summaries of the events leading to the characters' defeats and suggest that their deaths are implied but not confirmed. These sources are generally well-regarded within the fandom for their analysis and summaries of the series 35.

• ComicBook.com presents a more assertive stance, claiming that Big Mom's death is confirmed in the Elbaf arc. However, this assertion lacks direct citations from the manga itself, which raises questions about the reliability of their interpretation 4.

• Sportskeeda offers a more cautious approach, noting that while there are indications of Big Mom's death, there is no clear evidence for Kaido's demise. This source is known for its balanced reporting but should still be approached with some skepticism due to its speculative nature 810.

• Fandom discussions and user-generated content, such as those on the One Piece Wiki, often reflect personal opinions and speculation rather than established facts. While they can provide insight into community sentiment, they lack the editorial oversight that more formal sources possess 7.

Methodological Concerns

The claims surrounding the deaths of Kaido and Big Mom rely heavily on interpretations of manga chapters and subsequent discussions among fans. The lack of explicit confirmation within the source material itself complicates the analysis. Additionally, the potential for "fake-out" deaths in storytelling, especially in long-running series, adds another layer of uncertainty to the claims being made.

Conclusion

Verdict: Unverified

The status of Kaido and Big Mom remains unverified due to the lack of explicit confirmation of their deaths in the One Piece narrative. While some sources suggest that their deaths are implied, others argue that the ambiguity is intentional, leaving room for potential returns in future storylines. The ongoing debates within the fandom highlight the speculative nature of these claims, with interpretations varying widely among fans and commentators.

It is important to note that the evidence available is largely interpretative and lacks definitive statements from the source material. The potential for "fake-out" deaths in One Piece further complicates the situation, as the series has a history of misleading narratives regarding character fates.

Readers are encouraged to critically evaluate the information presented and consider the limitations of the available evidence when forming their own conclusions about the fates of Kaido and Big Mom.

Sources

1. One Piece season 19. (n.d.). Retrieved from Wikipedia
2. One Piece. (n.d.). Retrieved from Wikipedia
3. Are Kaido & Big Mom Really Dead In One Piece? - Animehunch. Retrieved from Animehunch
4. One Piece May Have Just Confirmed Big Mom’s Fate. (2025). Retrieved from ComicBook.com
5. Are Kaido and Big Mom Actually Dead in One Piece? - Attack of the Fanboy. Retrieved from Attack of the Fanboy
6. One Piece: Confirmed Deaths In Wano Country Arc. Retrieved from Otakusnotes
7. Is Kaido and Big Mom dead? | Fandom - One Piece Wiki. Retrieved from One Piece Fandom
8. One Piece: Is Big Mom dead or still alive? Explored - Sportskeeda. Retrieved from Sportskeeda
9. How Kaido's Death Could Be Another One Piece Fake-Out. (2024). Retrieved from CBR
10. One Piece chapter 1064 seemingly confirms Big Mom's fate - Sportskeeda. Retrieved from Sportskeeda