Are AHAs Safe During Pregnancy?
The claim regarding the safety of alpha-hydroxy acids (AHAs) during pregnancy has generated considerable discussion among skincare professionals and expectant mothers. AHAs, which include glycolic acid and lactic acid, are commonly used in skincare products for their exfoliating properties. However, the question remains: are they safe to use during pregnancy? This article will explore the available evidence and expert opinions on this topic without reaching a definitive conclusion.
What We Know
-
General Consensus on Safety: Many sources indicate that AHAs are generally considered safe for topical use during pregnancy, particularly in low concentrations. For example, a study published in the Journal of Cosmetic Dermatology states that certain moisturizers containing AHAs are safe for use during pregnancy due to low absorption levels through the skin 1.
-
Specific Recommendations: Healthline notes that glycolic acid, a common AHA, is typically safe in concentrations lower than 10% during pregnancy 3. Similarly, a blog by Dr. Laura Nicholas suggests that while most AHAs are deemed unsafe, glycolic acid at concentrations of 7% or lower can be used safely 4.
-
Absorption and Risk: The Royal Hospital for Women in Australia suggests that the absorption of AHAs through the skin is minimal, which contributes to their classification as low-risk during pregnancy 2. This is echoed by multiple sources, including a post from Parenthood Times, which emphasizes the importance of following usage instructions to avoid skin irritation 7.
-
Contradictory Opinions: Despite the general consensus, some sources argue against the use of AHAs during pregnancy. For instance, Dr. Laura Nicholas expresses caution, recommending alternatives to chemical exfoliants 4. Additionally, a blog from ShunChild states that while AHAs can be safe in small amounts, caution should be exercised 5.
-
Lack of Comprehensive Studies: It is important to note that while AHAs are widely used, comprehensive studies specifically examining their effects during pregnancy are lacking. BabyCenter mentions that AHAs have not been extensively studied in pregnant populations, which raises questions about their long-term safety 9.
Analysis
The evidence surrounding the safety of AHAs during pregnancy presents a mixed picture. On one hand, several credible sources, including health organizations and dermatology experts, suggest that AHAs can be safely used in moderation. The consensus appears to be that low concentrations of AHAs, particularly glycolic acid, pose minimal risk due to low systemic absorption.
However, the lack of extensive research specifically focused on pregnant populations is a significant gap in the available literature. The absence of large-scale studies means that while current guidelines may be based on existing knowledge, they are not definitive. This is particularly concerning given that pregnancy can alter skin sensitivity and reactions to topical products.
Furthermore, the potential for conflicting interests should be considered. Some sources may be influenced by commercial interests in skincare products, which could bias their recommendations. For example, beauty blogs and skincare brands may promote the use of AHAs to encourage sales, potentially downplaying risks.
Overall, while many dermatologists and health professionals advocate for the safe use of AHAs during pregnancy, the variability in expert opinions and the lack of comprehensive studies necessitate a cautious approach. Pregnant individuals are advised to consult healthcare providers before incorporating any new skincare products into their routines.
Conclusion
Verdict: Partially True
The claim that AHAs are safe to use during pregnancy is partially true. Evidence from various sources indicates that low concentrations of AHAs, particularly glycolic acid, are generally considered safe for topical use due to minimal absorption through the skin. However, there are conflicting opinions among experts, and some caution against their use altogether.
The primary limitation in reaching a definitive conclusion is the lack of comprehensive studies specifically examining the effects of AHAs on pregnant populations. While current guidelines suggest safety in moderation, the absence of extensive research leaves room for uncertainty regarding long-term effects.
Readers are encouraged to critically evaluate information and consult healthcare professionals when considering the use of AHAs or any skincare products during pregnancy.
Sources
- Putra, I. B. (2022). Skin Changes and Safety Profile of Topical Products. Journal of Cosmetic Dermatology. Retrieved from PMC
- Skin Care, Hair Care and Cosmetic Treatments in Pregnancy. Royal Hospital for Women. Retrieved from SES LHD
- Healthline. Is Glycolic Acid Safe During Pregnancy? Retrieved from Healthline
- Nicholas, L. (2020). Which Skincare Acids are Safe In Pregnancy? Retrieved from Dr. Laura Nicholas
- ShunChild. BHA And AHA Skincare: Safe During Pregnancy? Retrieved from ShunChild
- Nonie of Beverly Hills. Is it Safe to Use AHAs During Pregnancy? Retrieved from Nonie of Beverly Hills
- Parenthood Times. AHAs in Pregnancy Skincare: Are They Safe? Retrieved from Parenthood Times
- Nonie of Beverly Hills. Is it Safe to Use AHAs During Pregnancy? Retrieved from Nonie of Beverly Hills
- BabyCenter. Safe skin care during pregnancy. Retrieved from BabyCenter
- Amala Beauty. How to Determine if AHA/BHA Is Safe During Pregnancy. Retrieved from Amala Beauty
