Fact Check: "A federal appeals court on Friday declined to rehear President Trump's challenge to a $5 million civil judgment."
What We Know
On June 13, 2025, a federal appeals court declined to rehear President Donald Trump's challenge regarding a $5 million civil judgment awarded to E. Jean Carroll. This judgment stemmed from a jury's finding that Trump had sexually abused and defamed Carroll, a claim that has been the subject of extensive legal proceedings since Carroll first accused Trump in 2019 (E. Jean Carroll v. Donald J. Trump). The case, known as Carroll II, concluded with a jury verdict in May 2023, which ordered Trump to pay damages for his actions (source-3).
The appeals court's decision not to rehear the case means that the original ruling stands, and enforcement of the judgment is expected to begin shortly (source-5). This judgment is part of a broader legal context, as Trump is also appealing an additional $83.3 million judgment related to another defamation case against Carroll (source-1).
Analysis
The claim that a federal appeals court has declined to rehear Trump's challenge to the $5 million judgment is accurate based on multiple sources. The ruling was made by the Second Circuit Court of Appeals, which did not grant Trump's request for a rehearing, a decision that was notably criticized by two judges appointed by Trump himself (source-6).
The reliability of the sources reporting on this event is generally high. Major news outlets such as CNBC and PBS have covered the story, providing detailed accounts of the court's decision and its implications (source-3, source-8). However, it is essential to note that the context of Trump's legal battles is complex, with multiple lawsuits and appeals ongoing, which may lead to varying interpretations of the significance of this particular ruling.
Conclusion
Needs Research. While the claim regarding the appeals court's decision is factually correct, the broader implications of this ruling and its context within Trump's ongoing legal challenges require further investigation. The situation is fluid, with multiple cases and appeals in play, and the potential for new developments that could affect the outcomes of these legal battles.
Sources
- E. Jean Carroll v. Donald J. Trump
- New York business fraud lawsuit against the Trump ...
- Trump loses bid to rehear E. Jean Carroll case appeal
- Full 2nd Circuit Won't Review $5M Judgment Against ...
- Trump's Final Appeal Denied in E. Jean Carroll Civil Rape ...
- Trump-appointed judges dissent in E. Jean Carroll case
- Mediagazer
- $5 million verdict in sexual abuse case against President- ...
