Fact Check: A divided court left intact the decision upholding the jury's damage award.

Fact Check: "A divided court left intact the decision upholding the jury's damage award."

What We Know

The claim that "a divided court left intact the decision upholding the jury's damage award" appears to be accurate based on recent reports. Specifically, an appellate court has denied a request for an en banc hearing regarding a $5 million judgment against Donald Trump in the E. Jean Carroll case. This denial effectively maintains the jury's damage award, as noted in reports from ABC News and other outlets. The decision was made without further explanation, which is a common practice in such cases.

Analysis

The sources confirming the claim include both news articles and legal analysis. The report from ABC News explicitly states that the appellate court's decision was made by a divided panel, affirming the jury's award. This is corroborated by a similar report from MSN, which also mentions that the court's denial of an en banc hearing left the jury's award intact.

Both sources are credible, as they are established news organizations that report on legal matters. However, the lack of detailed commentary on the court's reasoning or the implications of the decision leaves some ambiguity. The absence of an explanation for the denial of the en banc hearing could indicate a reluctance to engage with the complexities of the case or a straightforward affirmation of the lower court's ruling without additional scrutiny.

Conclusion

Needs Research: While the claim that a divided court upheld the jury's damage award is supported by credible sources, the lack of detailed information about the court's reasoning and the broader context of the case necessitates further investigation. Understanding the implications of this decision and its potential impact on future cases would require additional sources and analysis.

Sources

1. On Juries and Damage Awards
2. A U.S. Supreme Court Case Update - Senate Office of Research
3. What's It Worth? Jury Damage Awards as Community ...
4. Don't Tell Juries about Statutory Damage Caps
5. Punitive Damages: A Comparative Analysis
6. Can a Judge Change a Jury's Decision on Liability or Damages?
7. Appeals court rejects Trump's bid to challenge $5 million E. Jean ... - MSN
8. Appeals court rejects Trump's bid to challenge $5 million E ...