Fact Check: "28 states sat out the fight against Trump's birthright citizenship order."
What We Know
The claim that "28 states sat out the fight against Trump's birthright citizenship order" suggests that a significant number of states did not participate in legal challenges against President Trump's executive order regarding birthright citizenship. However, the specific context of this claim is not well-documented in credible sources.
President Trump's executive order, issued in 2019, aimed to end the practice of granting citizenship to children born in the U.S. to non-citizen parents, a policy rooted in the 14th Amendment of the U.S. Constitution. Legal challenges arose from various states and advocacy groups, but the participation of states in these challenges varied widely.
While some states, particularly those with Democratic leadership, actively opposed the order, others remained silent or did not join the lawsuits. However, the exact number of states that "sat out" is not clearly defined in available literature, making it difficult to substantiate the claim of 28 states.
Analysis
The assertion that 28 states did not engage in the fight against Trump's birthright citizenship order lacks specific evidence and is not supported by detailed legal analysis or state-by-state breakdowns. Most credible discussions around this topic focus on the states that did participate in lawsuits, such as California and New York, which were vocal opponents of the executive order.
The lack of comprehensive data on the participation of all states in these legal battles raises questions about the reliability of the claim. Furthermore, the sources available do not provide a clear list or evidence of states that chose not to engage in the legal challenges. This absence of data suggests that the claim may be an oversimplification or misrepresentation of the situation.
Additionally, the sources referenced for this claim do not pertain to the topic of birthright citizenship or the legal challenges surrounding it, indicating a potential issue with source credibility and relevance.
Conclusion
Needs Research. The claim that "28 states sat out the fight against Trump's birthright citizenship order" is not substantiated by credible evidence or detailed analysis. The lack of specific data on state participation in legal challenges makes it difficult to verify the accuracy of this assertion. Further investigation and reliable sources are needed to clarify the involvement of states in this significant legal issue.
