Fact Check: Anti-Israel policies are anti-Texas policies.

Fact Check: Anti-Israel Policies Are Anti-Texas Policies

What We Know

The claim that "anti-Israel policies are anti-Texas policies" has been prominently stated by Texas Governor Greg Abbott. He articulated this viewpoint during the signing of House Bill 89 (HB 89) on May 2, 2017, which prohibits state agencies from contracting with companies that participate in the Boycott, Divestment, and Sanctions (BDS) movement against Israel. Abbott emphasized Texas's strong economic and cultural ties to Israel, stating, "I am proud to have commemorated Israel’s Independence Day by signing into law Anti-BDS legislation in Texas" (source-1).

In a more recent context, Abbott reiterated this stance in a letter condemning a proposed resolution by the City of San Marcos that aimed to halt funding to Israel. He described the resolution as "antisemitic" and stated, "Anti-Israel policies are anti-Texas policies" (source-3; source-5).

The legal framework supporting this claim includes the Texas anti-boycott law, which has been upheld by the Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals, affirming its constitutionality and necessity in light of perceived hostility toward Israel (source-2).

Analysis

The assertion that anti-Israel policies equate to anti-Texas policies is rooted in the legislative actions and public statements made by Texas officials, particularly Governor Abbott. The passage of HB 89 reflects a legislative intent to align Texas's economic interests with those of Israel, which Abbott has characterized as a vital ally (source-1; source-4).

Critics of this viewpoint argue that equating opposition to Israeli policies with antisemitism oversimplifies complex geopolitical issues and undermines legitimate discourse on foreign policy. The framing of anti-Israel sentiment as a direct threat to Texas's values may also reflect a broader political strategy aimed at consolidating support among conservative constituents who prioritize strong U.S.-Israel relations (source-7).

The sources cited in support of Abbott's claims, including official press releases and legal documents, are credible as they originate from government and judicial entities. However, the interpretation of these policies can vary significantly depending on the political lens through which they are viewed.

Conclusion

The claim that "anti-Israel policies are anti-Texas policies" is True based on the legislative actions taken by Texas and the explicit statements made by Governor Abbott. The state's legal framework, particularly the anti-boycott law, reinforces this assertion by linking Texas's economic policies directly to its support for Israel. While the claim is supported by official statements and legal backing, it is essential to recognize the broader implications and criticisms surrounding the framing of this issue.

Sources

1. Anti-Israel Policies Are Anti-Texas Policies
2. Paxton Wins Major Case Defending Texas's Anti-Boycott- ...
3. Governor Abbott Condemns City Of San Marcos Antisemitic ...
4. Being anti-Israel is anti-Texas, says Gov. Greg Abbott
5. Abbott stated "Anti-Israel policies are anti-Texas policies."
6. 'Anti-Israel policies are anti-Texas policies': Abbott slams ...
7. Texas Governor’s Shocking Claim: Anti-Israel = Anti-Texas!
8. A look at Texas's Pro-Israel Boycott Ban - CobbJohns